close

Join the QN5 community

close

Please login

Forgot your password?

Tonedeff TONE! “In Rainbows” vs rest of RH catalog

I would like to hear tone ‘s opinion on “in rainbows” is and how it stacks up to the other radiohead releases.


please feel free to give your opinion as well

if this has already been posted somewhere else i apologize i looked and saw no sign of it.

I want to hear what he thought of disc 2, since he took the plunge and bought that super-nice box set. I wonder how the other songs stack up to the main album.

ive only heard the main album, but its pretty good, better, imo, that there last couple of albums

I just got disc 2 a few days ago, I don’t really like it as much as disc 1 so far but I’ve only given it one listen through.

del preston said:ive only heard the main album, but its pretty good, better, imo, that there last couple of albums

If you mean Kid A/Amnesiac I’m going to have to disagree, I love those albums.

ooooo, personally cant stand them

del preston said:ooooo, personally cant stand them

They’re pretty out there…that’s why I love them ;D.

meh, just not my taste, i guess. but then again, im not really big into radiohead, more of just an average fan. i can always find something to like about my favorite bands groups (which is probly y they are faves, haha)

As most of you know, I’m an ultra-huge gigantoid Radiohead fan, so this prolly won’t come as much of a shock to you.

Personally, IN RAINBOWS is my favorite album of 2007 - and it still monopolizes my iPod the majority of the time. Song-wise, this is some of the strongest work they’ve put together in years, even moreso than the majority of Hail To The Thief, which I loved, despite it’s slightly schizophrenic tracklisting.

As a cohesive piece of music, it’s easily the most organic of their catalog. There’s really not much electro-trickery to be found, (save for a couple percussive sputters on “15 Steps”). This is a band that has completely reinvented its sound album after album after album, and In Rainbows (and the excellent Disc 2) is an album that feels uncontrived and natural on every level. It sounds as though they decided to just make some songs and not reinvent music this time. Granted, they still exhibit the ultra-layered studio-mastery they’ve become known for over the years, but it almost seems to me that this record is a concious effort to purposefully HOLD BACK the sound.

When bands like Sigur Ros or Mew have taken the RH sound and elevated it to such cacophonous levels, it only seems right that the band that artistically standardized that approach to recording holds it’s breath and pulls back on the reigns. Each song takes a pensive/ measured approach from its opening, to it’s zenith and to it’s close. Nothing every truly EXPLODES…and thankfully, it never needs to. And for a band that made EXPLODING an artform… it’s beautiful to watch the musical maturity needed to restrain from turning “All I Need” into an overproduced overlong exercise in thrashing and volume. The song only goes as far as it needs to and ends before it becomes what you expect it to… yet, you’re left with All You Need…quite literally.

“Arpeggi/Weird Fishes” is absolutely one of my favorites and I’m very pleased with the final version, as I’ve been listening to the live versions of these songs since they toured the states with them a couple years ago. “Nude” is one of the most beautiful songs I’ve heard in years, and the opening is goosebump inducing the first time you hear it. I could go on and on about it…but I won’t.

“Last Flowers To The Hospital” on Disc 2 is probably my favorite song they’ve done since “How To Disappear Completely”. The chord changes are about as haunting as it gets. Extremely refined, simplistic, and totally unique.

Also, on this album, they let their rock flag fly…and got down and dirty with some straight up clangy garage rock with “Bodysnatchers” and “Jigsaw Falling Into Place”. This is the Radiohead from The Bends that didn’t hesitate to throw a chainsaw-sized guitar riff into the middle of a ballad. “Bangers & Mash” is my shit, straight up and down. That’s as ill a breakbeat as you’d be able to pull off a 60’s rock record for a mashup. The drumming itself on this album also comes to the front alot on this album, on songs like “Reckoner” which is just played to a tee, each roll and fill… pitch perfectly hit at the right marks.

Overall, I can’t say enough about this album. My only gripe would be the final version of Videotape, but I did myself a disservice by getting attached to the live bootleg version of the song for a year+ before the CD dropped. I shoulda just waited, cause lyrically/melodically…it’s a beautiful fucking song. I’m just not sold on this particular arrangement of it. But letting myself get stuck on something that wasn’t the artists original intention is a fauxpau is a dummy’s snag, so I won’t even let that register.

9.5/10

In comparison to their other albums, there’s alot of different variables you have to take into account when comparing them (impact on music, time of release, etc etc), but this is definitely one of their Top 3, imo. I’d put it behind OKC and KID A.

Hollerate.
Tone.

Have you ever considered being a music journalist? That was a great review.

jjustin408 said:Have you ever considered being a music journalist? That was a great review.

Hahah thanks. Honestly, It’d prolly invoke way too much backlash if I attempted to do it while still being an “active” musician. Politically, you’re not really allowed to have negative opinions on other people’s music when you’re trying to build your own career. Perhaps I’ll dabble in it when I’m done with this rap stuff.

Word. On your side of the field, not saying anything about something is as much of a bad review as you can reasonably give without the backlash.

Speak on it if you love it, forever hold your peace otherwise. Crazy how that applies across the board—from stand-up comedy to hip-hop to journalism.

Agreed! Essentially, third verse of “Politics” addresses that whole issue directly.

Not to call you out or anything… but didn’t you (and Pack) take time out of both of your sets to say “Fuck Drake” on stage at CMJ last week? lol. I’m not going to take offense since i’m guessing you haven’t really listened or given him a fair shot. (The only other video on my youtube besides my “Gathered” piano cover is me playing over a Drake song..i’m a fan.)

amplifya said:Not to call you out or anything… but didn’t you (and Pack) take time out of both of your sets to say “Fuck Drake” on stage at CMJ last week? lol.

Never said that. I was talking about how people get caught up in the flavor of the month and may not be aware of QN5. I said and I quote >“tell that bitch to stop listening to drake records for 5 minutes and come fuck with us”. You can take that however you want.

I’m not going to take offense since i’m guessing you haven’t really listened or given him a fair shot. (The only other video on my youtube besides my “Gathered” piano cover is me playing over a Drake song..i’m a fan.)

...and I’m happy that you’re happy!

Hmm alright, sorry i brought it up

In Rainbows has become my favorite Radiohead album besides that its dope for the simple fact it’s the only one that isn’t depressing or emotionally draining to listen to..it’s the only one I don’t have to be in a certain mood to want to hear.

House of Cards is my favorite!

“In Rainbows” is an organic masterpiece. I was never a fan of Radiohead until I heard this. Which brings me to Thom Yorke’s solo album, “The Eraser”. It’s far more electronic-influenced than Radiohead’s music, yet it doesn’t fail to deliver emotions on various levels.
Have you heard it, Tone? If so, what do you think?

what do you think of Thom Yorke’s super group with Flea and the dude from REM?

It’s pretty fuckin’ cool if you ask me.

lol at my comments from about a year ago, saying i couldn’t stand kid a/amnesiac. what a fool…

Thom Yorke’s super group? What’s it called?

There should be a “Tonedeff’s Reviews” thread…

First review: Imogen Heap’s newest record Ellipse. I know Tone’s a fan so it’s okay to talk about it. Go. lol

Thom mostly made a super group so he could perform his Eraser album and some new stuff he’s been working on while he was in Los Angeles about two months ago

don’t think anything major is going to happen beyond their couple shows they did in LA

JLee said:Thom mostly made a super group so he could perform his Eraser album and some new stuff he’s been working on while he was in Los Angeles about two months ago

don’t think anything major is going to happen beyond their couple shows they did in LA

The show’s are Thom Yorke Live at Orpheum Theatre Oct. 4 & 5 2009.

It’s really good stuff. A few of my boy’s had a chance to see them and said it was nothing short of amazing. Is it as good as the Oysterhead super group I don’t know; but its good regardless.

he did a couple secret shows in addition to those too
all of which managed to slip past me or sell out before I could get tickets

October was a bit sad Sad